Online Courses for Teachers

Discovering Your Own Growth Mindset

In today’s modern society, we find ourselves in constant communication with one another via messaging apps or social media platforms. Perhaps no other time in history would bear witness to people so consumed with their sense of self. Dissatisfied with a product? Tweet out your disappointment to the universe. Indulging in a meal at your favorite burger joint? Slap a picture of your plate on Instagram. Having a good hair day? Upload a snap of those awesome tresses to your Snapchat story. Selfies, anyone? The list goes on and on.

As a result, many of us either knowingly or unknowingly expend a great deal of energy seeking out or labeling probable causes, which keeps us from reaching our goals. Thanks to social media, we are inherently aware of how we stack up compared to those around us. We repeat variations of statements like the ones below to validate the persistence of our predicaments.

• “I've always subscribed to this particular school of thought, so there’s no sense in changing now.”
• “I'm not good enough to ________.”
• “This is the way I was raised, so I am not going to question it.”
• “Why put forth so much energy and effort? It will never happen to/for me/you anyway.”
• “It’s too much work.”
• “I’m too old/out of shape/poor/etc.”

Perhaps you have even pronounced a few of these limiting phrases to yourself or to others while embroiled in debate or conversation. And yet, the question remains: why do we continue to champion for our limitations? The research confirms that our intelligence is not fixed, as we once believed it to be. Given the recent foray into studying the brain’s response to a variety of stimuli or tasks, we now know that the brain can readjust itself and evolve. If the hard science exists outside of it, surely the readjustment of our inner voice can subsist within us (Lynch, 2018). As the old adage goes, you can’t pour from an empty cup. In the same way, teachers who possess a fixed mindset of their own are not equipped with the tools or framework for “instilling a growth mindset” in those they influence and teach.

As teachers, we would be remiss if we did not consider the impact that our own assumptions and mindset has when it spills over into the classroom. Perhaps there are those among us who recall the “self-esteem” movement, and it’s likely there are those of us who may have been the target audience when we were in school. We know our students leave our classrooms and take part in a myriad of activities where they may receive a very mixed message on mindset. Perhaps early on, children become accustomed to the practice where every player on a team receives a medal for participation alone. This somewhat controversial practice can swing the pendulum in one of two ways. Some children may believe that ultimately, their effort and improvement was recognized even if s/he did not walk onto the field, immediately possessing the ability to play the game with ease. Other children may take this participation medal as a sign that it does not matter how well one tries or how much effort one exerts. In their eyes, everyone gets the same result and receives the same accolade, therefore nullifying a sense of competitiveness. Yet, as students age, they often find themselves the recipients of a fixed mindset way of doing things, when one is “cut” or fails to earn a spot in the school musical or the basketball team on the basis of their inherent skills or abilities.

We occupy a world which is mesmerized by the idea of “genius” and “giftedness” and how early it can be discovered or assessed. Videos go viral across social media platforms of child prodigies who are able to play Tchaikovsky by ear or teens who can play through all the levels on a popular video game while blindfolded. Every four years, we sit glued to our televisions watching the Olympic games, reveling in the belief that a particular phenom was “destined” to play or compete in a particular sport. The media hypes up the idea of a predetermined or inborn talent without acknowledging how these stories often dismiss hard work and grit. As the groan-worthy joke goes, “How do you get to Carnegie Hall? Practice, practice, practice!"

Consider the table below (Bolton, 2015) and note the differences in statements uttered or associated by those in possession of a particular mindset. Do you find yourself aligning with any of the statements made?

Growth vs. Fixed Mindset

Let’s recall that the most prominent line between the two mindsets is the belief in the permanence of intelligence and ability. One views it as a constant, with little-to-no room for change in either direction. Meanwhile, the other mindset is characterized as being more prone to change, with opportunities for improvement. These differences may result in noticeable differences in behavior as well. If someone believes intelligence and abilities are static traits, it is unlikely that s/he will be willing to put forth much effort to attempt to change his/her level of intelligence or ability. Alternately, those who believe they are in control and have the power to change said traits will possess the grit needed to put in extra time and effort in the pursuit of more ambitious goals or endeavors. Those in possession of a growth mindset are more likely to use their time productively as opposed to worrying constantly about being the best or illuminating their talents to those around them. This provides them with the freedom to think creatively and place a more concentrated effort upon building up their intelligence and interests (Dweck, 2015).

While the benefits of instilling a growth mindset in students are tenfold, Dweck does not hesitate to point out that it’s not just about telling yourself (or others) that you “can improve.” Having a growth mindset is not about being open-minded or being a flexible thinker. It is more precise than this. It is not just about praising and rewarding effort, as that is not necessarily tied to measurable outcomes. Being passionate about establishing a flexible mindset or cultivating one in the students you serve may lead to positive outcomes; but it is not a guarantee. The mindset must be supported by carefully curated activities and even then, student success or personal success is not a foregone conclusion. Rather, a growth mindset is a way of thinking which is something that all teachers should strive to give their students. When we live with a growth mindset, we see possibilities instead of limitations. Our failures become valuable experiences for learning. Success attained by others should inspire us rather than provoke a feeling of self-doubt or jealousy. Most of all, we should view our efforts as important steps on the pathway to a meaningful journey rather than as a bridge to nowhere. This is the kind of self-awareness we must foster in ourselves in order to be equipped to prepare our students to succeed in exciting ventures, which will stretch far beyond the bounds and limitations of the traditional school model (Dweck, 2015).

Consider what damage can be done when teachers or parents claim to embrace or implement a growth mindset in themselves or their homes, but lack the tools to follow through. In recent findings, Dweck herself found that there were many teachers who endorsed a growth mindset and even said the words “growth mindset” continuously within their classrooms, but failed to follow through with meaningful classroom practices. As a result, the students in these courses tended to endorse more of a fixed mindset about their abilities. Longtime Dweck collaborator, Kyla Haimovitz (2016), finds that many parents are quick to endorse a growth mindset but react to their children’s mistakes as if these errors are a harmful byproduct, instead of a helpful mistake. In these instances, the only mindset — which flourishes and is fostered — is highly characteristic of a fixed one.

One of the best things that you can do is to take an honest assessment of your own mindset. Realistically, is it more characteristic of a fixed or growth mindset? Perhaps you’re the person who was referenced earlier who fluctuates on the mindset continuum, depending upon the given situation. Keeping an open mind, take some time to complete the mindset quiz below and see if your results align with your own self-assessment.

I have a fixed mindset. Now What?

The key to changing your mindset lies first and foremost with being self-aware. In order to manipulate your mindset, you must be able to identify situations which commonly trigger your fixed mindset, so that you can be aware of when you’re falling into similar patterns of statements or beliefs.

The following are four key guidelines which can be used to begin retraining your brain toward a growth mindset (Dweck, 2017).

1. Learn to hear your fixed mindset voice. When faced with a new challenge, this “voice” might whisper, “Are you sure you can do it?” “What if you fail?” When encountering a setback, this voice may say, “If only you had a natural talent,” or “It looks as if it did not pay for you take the risk.” In the face of feedback from a colleague, the fixed mindset voice says, “This is not your fault,” or “Who do they think they are to criticize me”?
In order to retrain your brain, you must first learn to listen to see if this “voice” creeps in from time to time. If so, you must learn to shut it down before it has time to take seed in your conscience. Be conscious of fixed mindset triggers. Think about how you feel when you experience a setback during teaching. Perhaps the lesson did not go as planned or the students aren’t engaged or demonstrating their learning proficiently. Do you feel incompetent or defeated? Do you wish you had not even bothered? Do you look for a way to excuse your actions in order to pass the blame to someone else? Perhaps it is criticism (well-intentioned or otherwise) that sparks thoughts typically associated with a fixed mindset. Do you become defensive or angry? Are you able to return to the feedback to flesh out its value once your “big” feelings have subsided? If you see a colleague receiving accolades for something you have a passion or interest in, do you feel maligned, envious, and threatened? Or do you respond by asking him/her for counsel or the opportunity to watch him/her in action? Live with, feel, and accept those fixed mindset thoughts and feelings. Then put in the work to get through them. Always be on the lookout for key opportunities for growth.
2. Recognize that you have a choice. When the voice of doubt begins to creep in, turn that frown upside down and take the challenges, criticism, and missteps as a sign for self-improvement. Respond by deciding to challenge yourself through new learning opportunities, change your strategies, and strive to develop new methodologies or tactics to confront perceived shortcomings.
3. Respond to the “inner voice” with a growth mindset voice. In essence, change the dialogue, much like the following.
• The fixed mindset voice says, “You can’t do this.” The growth mindset voice retorts, “I’m not sure I can do it just yet, but I think that with time and effort, I can continue to improve and learn.
• The fixed mindset voice says, “If you fail, your colleagues, students, and principal will always think of you as a failure.” The growth mindset voice replies, “Most successful people encountered their own failures on the pathway to success. I can set a great example for my students by being transparent about my mistakes and sharing what I plan to do the next time so that I can avoid similar errors.”
• The fixed mindset says, “It’s not your fault. The ________ (student, colleague, friend, parent, administrator, stakeholder) contributed to the setback.” The growth mindset voice takes responsibility and responds, “If I do not accept my role, then I won’t be able to correct or prevent the same mistake from happening in the future.”

Some people even find it therapeutic and helpful to journal their fixed mindset thoughts as they enter their minds so that they can be addressed using a growth mindset voice. By recording these thoughts, a pattern begins to emerge whereby one is able to glean what sparked the fixed mindset in the first place. Be sure to review all of the dialogues so that they become commonplace in your mind.

4. Take growth mindset action. Once you have responded to the fixed mindset voice inside you, combat it with specific and measurable actions. An action plan might include embarking on a new challenge, persisting through an old challenge once abandoned, or looking for ways to improve your craft through professional development, professional text, or positive mentorship relationships.

After you have challenged the fixed mindset voice with growth mindset practice, it can also be helpful to ask yourself the right questions (Park, 2016). The following is a sampling of questions which can be used for reflection purposes as you work toward determining what your next steps will be. Ultimately, it is questions such as these that serve to assist you as you plan the next steps in your growth mindset action plan. They also make for great “starters” if you choose to journal the fixed vs. growth mindset dialogue as mentioned previously.

• What can I learn from this?
• What steps can I take to help me succeed?
• Do I recognize the outcome or goal I’m after?
• What information can I gather? And from where?
• Where can I get constructive feedback?
• How will I follow through on my plan?
• What did I learn from this experience (positive or negative)?
• What mistake(s) did I make that taught me something?
• Is my current learning strategy working? If not, how can I change it?
• What did I try hard at today?
• What habits must I develop in order to continue the gains I’ve achieved?

It’s a Process

In order to guide ourselves toward the consistent adoption of a deeper and well-developed growth mindset that illuminates our classroom practices, we must acknowledge the existence of the fixed mindset. We must realize we are all a mixture of fixed and growth mindset habits and tendencies and in order to foster the development of a growth mindset, we must honor and combat our fixed mindset thoughts and actions (Dweck, 2017). The background information and understanding that was gleaned from this article can be used to lay a solid foundation for the successful commitment to beginning or continuing the work of Dweck and her colleagues. Interested in hearing about growth mindset directly from guru Carol Dweck? Watch her TED talk to take a deeper dive into growth mindset theory.

Are you curious? Want to take a deep dive on this topic?

To learn more about how to instill a growth mindset in students, visit the Professional Development Institute (PDI) website or go directly to our Instilling a Growth Mindset in Students course.

For over 27 years, PDI has provided high-quality and affordable online professional development courses to K-12 teachers worldwide. Our online courses are designed to offer practical strategies that can be implemented in classrooms immediately. All our courses are instructor-led and conducted entirely online. Graduate-level university credit for every PDI online course for teachers is available through the University of California San Diego Division of Extended Studies. PDI offers an extensive catalog of online courses that cover the most critical topics in today's classrooms.

References:

Bolton, J. (2015). “Intelligence as a Malleable Construct.” Retrieved 09 May 2019 from https://akamaihawaii.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/Malleable-Intelligence-Combo.pdf

Dweck, C.S. (2015). “Carol Dweck Revisits Growth Mindset.” Retrieved 02 May 2019 from https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2015/09/23/carol-dweck-revisits-the-growth-mindset.html?qs=carol+dweck

Dweck, C.S. (2017) “The Journey to Children’s Mindsets.” In Child Development Perspectives, 11(2), 151-155.

Haimovitz, K. (2016). “Parents’ View of Failure Predict Children’s Fixed and Growth Mind-Sets.” In Psychological Science, 27(6), 859-69.

Horn, I. S., Kane, B. D., & Wilson, J. (2015). “Making sense of student performance data: Data use logics and mathematics teachers’ learning opportunities.” In American Educational Research Journal, 52(2), 208–242.

Lynch, J. (2018). “The Perils of a Good Research Story.” Retrieved 18 June 2019 from https://medium.com/@quixotic_scholar/growth-mindset-the-perils-of-a-good-research-story-d6ce32a447d2

Park, D. (2016). “Young children’s motivational frameworks and math achievement: Relation to teacher-reported instructional practices, but not teacher theory of intelligence.” In Journal of Educational Psychology, 22(1), 315-17.

Rae-Dupree, J. (2008). “If You’re Open to Growth, You Tend to Grow.” Retrieved 06 June 2019 from https://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/06/business/06unbox.html?mtrref=undefined&gwh=457BF2A4328B505685D35689CE36C6B1&gwt=pay&assetType=REGIWALL

Categories: growth mindset, social and emotional learning